Where to Eat in Martha’s Vineyard: Local Favorites by Town
Whether you’re visiting Martha’s Vineyard for the first time or returning for another unforgettable summer, one of the best ways to experience the island is through its food. With each town offering its own charm and flavor, we’ve put together a curated list of restaurant recommendations from a full-time local who’s spent years discovering the best spots across the island.
In Edgartown, you'll find an exceptional mix of upscale and casual dining. Start with 19 Raw, a no-reservations raw bar that’s perfect for fresh oysters and light bites. For a more refined sit-down experience, The Covington, Atria, and Detente all offer seasonal menus and take reservations — ideal for a date night or a celebratory dinner. If you're in the mood for something lively and vibrant, Atlantic is a local favorite with no reservations required.
For those who want to explore beyond Edgartown, there are some true gems around the island. In Aquinnah, make time for Outermost Inn — not only is the food excellent, but the views alone make it one of the most memorable dining experiences on the Vineyard. In Chilmark, locals love Chilmark Tavern, which delivers great food in a warm, welcoming setting. It’s a perfect way to enjoy a quieter, more rustic part of the island.
Vineyard Haven offers a few great options as well — try Beach Road for waterfront dining and Garde East (listed as “9 Craft” in the note) for a more elevated experience. In West Tisbury, head to State Road, a longstanding favorite known for thoughtful dishes and a cozy, farmhouse atmosphere.
Whether you're hopping town to town or spending most of your time in one place, Martha’s Vineyard has no shortage of fantastic food. These picks strike the perfect balance of local charm, quality ingredients, and authentic Vineyard character — and they come straight from someone who moved here full-time after falling in love with the island summers. Bon appétit!
